Why audio-to-MIDI adds extra notes, and how to remove them
Most converted MIDI has the right notes in it, plus some that shouldn’t be there: a quiet note an octave up, a cluster of tiny notes, a low note that nobody played. It’s usually faster to remove extras than to hunt for missing notes, and once you know where they come from you can stop many of them at the source.
Where extra notes come from
- Overtones: every real note also sounds at higher pitches (an octave, an octave plus a fifth, two octaves). Loud ones can be read as separate notes, so you see quiet doubles above the real note.
- Noise: breaths, consonants, pick and key noise, fret buzz and room noise become very short notes.
- Reverb and ringing: notes that keep sounding after they were played (room echo, sustain pedal, open strings) overlap the next notes or come out as extra ones.
- Other instruments: anything else in the recording adds its own notes.
Stop them at the source
- Record one instrument or voice, dry, in a quiet room.
- Use less pedal and mute strings you aren’t playing.
- Keep the level steady: very loud notes produce strong overtones, very quiet passages let noise compete.
Settings that remove most of them
Open “Conversion settings” on the converter page. Changes re-read the original conversion, so you can try values and go back.
- Shortest note: raise it to drop the tiny notes noise produces. Go up step by step until the fast real notes start to disappear, then back off one step.
- Note sensitivity: lower it to drop quiet notes, which are mostly overtones and noise.
- Keep melody only: for a single line (voice, lead, flute), this keeps only the top note at each moment and removes everything underneath.
Bulk clean-up with the assistant
Ask for things like “remove notes shorter than 80 ms” or “keep only the melody”. The assistant previews the change and tells you how many notes would change; nothing happens until you press Apply, and Undo brings everything back.
Remove the rest by hand
- In the piano roll, quiet notes are drawn fainter and low-confidence notes are marked. Those are the first suspects.
- Drag on empty paper to box-select a group of stray notes, then press Delete.
- Shift-click to pick several scattered notes at once.
- Before deleting an octave double, play that bar: sometimes the higher note is real.
Check by ear, then export
Play the MIDI against the original once more. When it sounds like the recording, export the .mid and bring it into your DAW.