Piano to MIDI: convert a piano recording, and why chords are harder
Solo piano is one of the best cases for automatic transcription: one instrument, clear attacks, stable pitch. A single-line melody usually comes out close to right. Chords, fast passages and heavy pedal are harder, and it helps to know why before you start fixing notes.
What to expect
- A melody played one note at a time: usually close, with a few notes to fix.
- Chords and accompaniment: most notes come through, but expect some missing inner notes and a few extra ones.
- Fast runs and trills: notes can merge or be skipped.
- Piano in a full band mix: the converter can’t tell which notes are piano. Use a solo piano recording when you can.
Why chords are harder
Every piano note also sounds its overtones: a C rings at the C an octave up, the G above that, and so on. In a chord, those overtones land on top of other real notes, so the converter has to decide which pitches you played and which are just ringing along. It sometimes adds a quiet octave or fifth that isn’t there, or drops a middle note that is hidden under the others.
The sustain pedal adds to this: notes keep sounding after you lift your fingers, so they can come out longer than played or overlap the next chord.
Record so the conversion has an easier job
- Record the piano alone. A phone near the instrument is fine; a digital piano’s line out is even better.
- Use the pedal lightly, or not at all, for the take you convert.
- Play at a steady, moderate volume. Very soft notes are the ones that go missing.
- Convert one section at a time instead of a whole piece.
Convert and check by ear
Drop the recording into the audio-to-MIDI converter (MP3 or WAV, up to 5 minutes on a computer). Nothing is uploaded; it runs in your browser. Play it back with both the original and the MIDI and listen for wrong notes; the built-in “Piano melody” example shows what a clean result looks like.
Settings that help with piano
- Keep melody only: if you only need the tune, this keeps the highest note at each moment and removes the chords under it. It works best when the melody really is on top.
- Note sensitivity: lower it if quiet ringing turns into extra notes, raise it if soft chord notes go missing.
- Shortest note: raise it if pedal noise or fast ornaments leave lots of tiny notes.
Fix the rest, then export
In the piano roll, delete stray octave notes, double-click an empty spot to add a missing chord note, and shorten notes the pedal stretched. The assistant can do bulk clean-up such as removing very short notes or quantizing. Then export the .mid and import it into your DAW.