A free alternative to Melodyne for audio to MIDI
Melodyne by Celemony is the reference tool for editing pitch and timing inside audio. Exporting what it detects as a MIDI file is one of its features. ohtune does only that part: turn a recording into MIDI, check it, fix it, export. If audio-to-MIDI is all you need, here's how the two compare, based on Celemony's own pages in November 2026.
The short version
- Want to correct the pitch or timing of the audio itself (tuning vocals, fixing a note in a guitar take): that's Melodyne's job, and ohtune doesn't do it.
- Want the notes of a recording as a MIDI part, for free: ohtune.
- Already own Melodyne Assistant or higher: you can export MIDI from it; ohtune is still handy when you're away from your DAW.
Which Melodyne editions export MIDI
Melodyne 5 comes in four editions: essential, assistant, editor and studio. Celemony's comparison lists “Audio-to-MIDI – export notes to a MIDI file” for assistant, editor and studio, not essential. Notes from polyphonic instruments such as piano or guitar (the DNA algorithm) need editor or studio. Celemony's web shop listed them at US$99, US$249, US$399 and US$699 in November 2026, and there's a 30-day free trial.
How ohtune differs
- Free, no account, nothing to install: it runs in the browser on a computer or phone.
- The audio stays on your device; the note model (Spotify's open-source Basic Pitch) runs in the browser.
- Handles one instrument or voice best; chords work with some extra notes to clean up. Melodyne's polyphonic detection is more refined.
- You fix notes in a piano roll while hearing the MIDI next to the original, then export a .mid with the detected tempo.
Plugin vs website
Every Melodyne edition runs standalone or as a plugin (VST3, AU, AAX) inside your DAW on macOS and Windows, so it fits into a session. ohtune is a separate page: convert, fix, export the .mid, then drag it into your DAW.
When Melodyne is the better choice
- You need to edit the audio, not just get MIDI from it.
- You work with dense polyphonic material and want the most accurate note detection.
- You want it inside your DAW as a plugin.